① Justification: US and Israel cite 'imminent threat,' but IAEA says there is no evidence Iran is building a nuclear bomb
② Strategy: Trump says 'most of the people we had in mind are dead' — with no clear exit plan, Khamenei's second son emerges as likely successor
③ Evacuation: No advance warning, no charter flights arranged before strikes — critics say Americans in the Middle East were told to fend for themselves
Criticism is mounting that the US-Israeli strikes on Iran amount to a war waged without justification, strategy or a plan to protect American civilians. The "imminent threat" from Iran that Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu cited to justify a preemptive strike has found no support from US intelligence agencies or the International Atomic Energy Agency. While the United States and Israel have demonstrated overwhelming superiority in intelligence and military mobilization, neither has offered a clear blueprint for an exit strategy. Four days into the air campaign, the US government is still scrambling to arrange charter flights for its citizens — a stark contrast to past operations in which evacuations were organized weeks in advance. Criticism from Congress and across the country has been swift and fierce.
Washington and Jerusalem have insisted the surprise preemptive strike — launched while nuclear negotiations with Iran were still under way — was a defensive measure. Speaking in a video address shortly after the strikes began, Trump said the goal was "to protect the American people by eliminating the imminent threat posed by the Iranian regime." He repeated the justification Tuesday during bilateral talks with German Chancellor Friedrich Merz at the White House, saying, "We were negotiating with these maniacs, and I thought they were going to strike first. They were about to attack. If we hadn't done it, they would have hit us first."
But the claim that Iran was on the verge of attacking the United States or its allies is at odds with assessments by US intelligence agencies and the IAEA. American intelligence officials concluded that Iran would not possess missiles capable of reaching the US mainland for at least nine years, through 2035. The Department of Homeland Security's Office of Intelligence and Analysis also assessed that the likelihood of Iran carrying out a "large-scale physical attack" on US soil was low, according to Reuters. IAEA Director General Rafael Grossi said Tuesday that while Iran's large stockpile of weapons-grade enriched uranium and its refusal to grant inspectors full access "raise serious concerns," he was unequivocal that "there is no evidence whatsoever that Iran is manufacturing a nuclear bomb."
Within the administration, some officials have offered positive assessments, saying targets are being neutralized faster than expected. But the absence of a clear exit strategy remains a glaring weakness. Regime change in Iran was one of Washington's stated objectives, yet Trump acknowledged Tuesday that "most of the people we had in mind are dead." The goal of establishing a peaceful democratic government after the death of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei now appears to be slipping away.
The contrast with the Venezuela operation is striking. Before moving against President Nicolás Maduro, the United States reached a comprehensive agreement with Delcy Rodríguez — now serving as interim president — on political stabilization in the event of a leadership vacuum, and only then launched military action.
Instead, the situation appears to be moving in the opposite direction from what Washington intended. According to The New York Times, Mojtaba Khamenei, the second son of the late Supreme Leader Ayatollah Seyyed Ali Khamenei, is emerging as the leading candidate to succeed his father. He holds no official government title but wields strong influence over the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and the intelligence services through his father's legacy. Should he take power with the IRGC's active backing, the Khamenei regime's political orientation would in effect continue uninterrupted.
Unlike past US military operations, in which citizens were evacuated before strikes began, the administration waited four days into the campaign before scrambling to arrange departures — another source of sharp criticism. The Department of State said Tuesday it was "supporting charter flight operations departing from the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia and Jordan for US citizens" and would "continue to secure additional transportation capacity as the security situation permits." Even that statement offered no concrete details, amounting to little more than an assurance that officials were trying.
Americans trying to flee Israel — exposed to retaliatory strikes by Iran and its proxies — found commercial air routes closed and turned instead to shuttle services run by Israel's Tourism Ministry through the Taba border crossing into Egypt. Even then, the US Embassy said it could offer "no recommendation either way" and that "the US government cannot guarantee your safety." Evacuation advisories for Americans and diplomats across 14 Middle Eastern countries were issued either just before or days after the Iranian strikes began. During the 2003 invasion of Iraq, evacuation orders went out weeks before operations commenced.
Congress erupted in criticism over the State Department's belated response. Democratic Sen. Andy Kim wrote on X, formerly Twitter, that warning citizens to evacuate on the third day of a war with airspace already closed was "a clear signal that the Trump administration has ZERO strategy and ZERO planning." Former Republican Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene — once an ardent Trump supporter who recently broke with the administration before resigning — was equally scathing. "American taxpayers are forced to give Israel $3.8 billion every year, and the US Embassy in Jerusalem is telling Americans good luck and you're on your own," she said. "This betrayal is unbelievable."
kate01@heraldcorp.com