Concern is growing in the mergers and acquisitions industry after President Lee Jae Myung directly raised the pro-rata approach as a key issue in the debate over mandatory tender offer rules. Industry participants warn that even if the mandatory tender offer volume is capped at "50% plus one share" of total shares, granting controlling and minority shareholders equal selling opportunities could chill control transactions.
Three options put forward by Lee — pro-rata emerges as flashpoint
According to investment banking industry sources, President Lee outlined three key issues surrounding the mandatory tender offer system at a capital markets policy forum held at the Korea Exchange in Yeouido, Seoul, on Friday.
The first option is a 100% mandatory tender offer, requiring an acquirer to purchase all shares that selling shareholders wish to tender. The second allows an acquirer to buy only a portion of total shares, with the controlling shareholder's stake acquired first and the remainder offered to general shareholders through a tender offer. The third is a pro-rata approach, under which partial purchases are permitted but selling opportunities are distributed proportionally among both the controlling shareholder and general shareholders based on their respective holdings.
Lee spelled out the issues in detail, asking whether the requirement should cover all shares or only a portion, and if partial, whether minority shareholders should also be given a pro-rata selling opportunity or whether the controlling shareholder's stake should be purchased first with only the remainder offered to minority shareholders. While expressing support for the intent behind mandatory tender offer rules, Lee pressed market participants for their views on the potential side effects for the M&A market.
The capital markets act amendment currently pending in the National Assembly corresponds to the second option. Under the bill, when an acquirer secures a stake of 25% or more to become the largest shareholder, it must acquire at least "50% plus one share" of total issued shares — but prior acquisition of the controlling shareholder's stake is permitted.
'Market slowdown inevitable' — incentives to deal shrink for both buyers and sellers
The M&A industry is opposed to both the 100% mandatory tender offer and the pro-rata approach. Either option, the industry argues, would significantly alter the existing structure of control transactions and risk cooling the M&A market.
For a 100% mandatory tender offer, the biggest concern is the sheer scale of financing an acquirer would need to raise. The pro-rata approach is also seen as a barrier to completing deals. Unlike the model that allows the controlling shareholder's stake to be acquired first, the pro-rata structure reduces the incentive for both sellers and buyers to proceed.
Consider a scenario in which an acquirer launches a tender offer for "50% plus one share" of a listed company whose controlling shareholder holds a 60% stake. If all shareholders tender their entire holdings, the controlling shareholder would be able to sell only about half of that stake. The remaining roughly 30% would stay with the original controlling shareholder. By contrast, if prior acquisition of the controlling shareholder's stake is permitted, the acquirer can complete the control transaction by securing the full 60% stake outright.
From the seller's perspective, this means continuing to hold a substantial stake even after relinquishing control. For a controlling shareholder seeking a clean exit and full recovery of invested capital, the transaction becomes far less attractive.
The burden falls on the buyer as well. If the former controlling shareholder remains as the second-largest shareholder, conflicts of interest could arise during future management even after control has been secured. Particularly in buyout transactions — where a private equity fund acquires a company, improves operations and then exits — the ongoing relationship with the former controlling shareholder can affect both the investment and the exit strategy.
"Under the pro-rata approach, the controlling shareholder who sold control could remain as a significant second-largest shareholder," said an official at a private equity fund manager. "The acquirer would have to keep managing that relationship even after securing control, which adds considerable uncertainty to the deal."
'Is the M&A slowdown argument backed by evidence?' — Debate over overseas cases and empirical research
The asset management industry and some academics push back, arguing that fears of an M&A slowdown are overstated. Their contention is that if the control premium paid by an acquirer to the controlling shareholder is also distributed to general shareholders, the total acquisition cost does not necessarily rise in proportion to the volume of shares purchased.
Kim Woo-chan, a professor at Korea University, said at the forum that a comparison of 41 countries before and after the introduction of mandatory tender offer rules showed an increase in tender offers targeting general shareholders. "Interest rates are now low and acquisition financing is active," Kim said. "We also need to factor in that premiums for control may fall once mandatory tender offers are introduced." Kim argued that changes in the domestic capital market environment mean M&A activity would not contract even if mandatory tender offer rules were introduced immediately.
Financial regulators, however, maintain that research also exists showing mandatory tender offer rules could have a negative impact on the M&A market. An FSC official at the forum said EU research and views from M&A industry participants point to contrary findings as well, adding that interpretations of positive and negative effects differ depending on academic methodology.
Japan allows partial purchases but prohibits prior acquisition of the controlling shareholder's stake. When a buyer acquires 30% or more of shares, a tender offer is required, and both the controlling shareholder and general shareholders participate in the offer together. If tendered shares exceed the planned purchase volume, they are allocated on a pro-rata basis. The United Kingdom, Hong Kong and Singapore, in principle, require a tender offer for all remaining shares. Even where prior acquisition of the controlling shareholder's stake is permitted, general shareholders must be given the opportunity to sell their entire holdings.
park.jiyeong@heraldcorp.com