Kospi PER falls to 3.5x amid sharp selloff
Yield gap tops 8 percentage points, signaling undervaluation
Cheap prices don't guarantee a rebound
Undervaluation may persist — patience required
Next market leaders may lie beyond AI and semiconductors
Every time share prices plunge, investors fixate on one question: how far will they fall? Those already holding stocks agonize over how long to ride out the decline, while those hunting for entry points hesitate over when to buy. The fear of further losses competes with the fear of missing a sudden rebound.
The problem is that calling the exact bottom of a stock market in advance is virtually impossible. What investors can do is gauge whether current prices are cheap or expensive relative to corporate earnings, and how attractive equities look compared with other asset classes. The two most widely used tools for this are the price-to-earnings ratio, or PER, and the yield gap.
Once investors have assessed valuation, the next question is timing. A stock being cheap does not mean it will rise immediately. Undervaluation can persist for a long time, and even when the market does recover, the sectors that led the previous rally are not guaranteed to lead the next one.
What investors need right now, therefore, is not just a judgment on how cheap prices have become, but a broader view that also takes in how long they may need to wait — and which industries are likely to drive the next market cycle.
Domestic markets have recently endured extreme volatility. A sweeping Democratic Party victory in the US midterm elections — what commentators called a "blue tsunami" — amplified fears of tighter regulation on the AI industry. Those concerns combined with growing doubts about AI's near-term profitability to trigger a sharp correction. The Kospi fell roughly 45 percent from its peak at one point, a steeper decline than during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The selloff is all the more puzzling given that Samsung Electronics and SK hynix are posting record earnings. Companies are making money, yet share prices have tumbled — a sign that markets are pricing in future uncertainty far more heavily than current results.
A deeper correction than COVID — how cheap are stocks now?
The first metric to examine is the PER. Simply put, it shows how expensive a stock is relative to the earnings the company generates. Think of it like buying a small business.
Suppose a shop earns 10 million won ($7,500) in net profit each year. If acquiring it costs 100 million won, the PER is 10 times — you are paying ten years' worth of earnings. If the same shop can be had for 50 million won, the PER drops to five times. All else being equal, the cheaper deal is clearly more attractive.
Stocks work the same way. A lower PER generally means the share price is inexpensive relative to earnings; a higher PER means the opposite. Companies with strong growth prospects can command elevated PERs because investors expect them to earn far more in the future.
The Kospi's average PER over the past decade, based on projected earnings over the next 12 months, has been around 10 times. When the market sold off sharply in early November, that figure briefly fell to around 3.5 times — an exceptionally low level by historical standards.
On the surface, that looks like a compelling buying opportunity. But there is a catch.
PER is calculated by dividing the share price by earnings per share. It falls when prices drop, but it also falls when earnings surge. The Kospi's currently depressed PER reflects the exceptionally high earnings forecasts for chipmakers such as Samsung Electronics and SK hynix.
The real question is whether those earnings can hold. A shop that earns 10 million won this year looks very different if profits shrink to 3 million won next year. What seemed like a bargain acquisition could turn out to be an expensive one.
Domestic chipmakers face a similar uncertainty. Expectations for AI's long-term growth remain strong, but when — and how generously — the enormous capital being poured into data centers and semiconductors will translate into returns is far from clear. If corporate capital expenditure slows, semiconductor demand and earnings forecasts will shift accordingly.
A low PER alone, then, is not sufficient grounds to conclude that stocks are deeply undervalued. Investors also need to assess whether current earnings levels are sustainable.
So how attractive are current prices relative to other asset classes? That is where the second metric, the yield gap, comes in.
The yield gap sounds technical, but the concept is straightforward. Think of it as a scale that compares the relative appeal of stocks against bonds.
The calculation starts by inverting the PER to derive the earnings yield. A PER of 10 times gives an earnings yield of 10 percent; a PER of 8 times gives 12.5 percent. It converts the relationship between price and earnings into a rate-of-return figure for comparison purposes.
An earnings yield of 12.5 percent does not mean an investor will earn 12.5 percent annually by buying the stock. Corporate earnings are not paid out directly to shareholders in full. It is purely a calculated rate used to assess the relative price level of equities.
Subtracting the government bond yield from the earnings yield produces the yield gap. If the earnings yield is 12 percent and the bond yield is 4 percent, the yield gap is 8 percentage points — meaning equities offer a calculated 8-percentage-point premium over bonds.
When share prices fall further, the earnings yield rises and, all else being equal, the yield gap widens. Conversely, rising share prices or rising bond yields compress the gap.
A wider yield gap is generally interpreted as equities becoming more attractive relative to bonds. The Kospi's PER excluding semiconductors currently stands at around 8 times, implying an earnings yield of roughly 12 percent. With the three-year government bond yield in the mid-3 percent range, the yield gap exceeds 8 percentage points — a significant improvement in the relative appeal of stocks over bonds.
Over the past decade, the yield gap for the Kospi excluding semiconductors has generally moved between 4 and 10 percentage points. It fell to around 4 percentage points during the bull run in the first half of this year, then widened again as share prices tumbled.
The numbers suggest the market has moved past the phase when elevated expectations eroded equities' relative value, and has now entered a range where undervaluation is worth examining seriously.
Cheap doesn't automatically mean higher
With both PER and yield gap flashing undervaluation signals, should investors expect an imminent rebound? Not necessarily. The critical distinction to keep in mind is that "cheap" and "ready to rise" are two very different things.
Even the best merchandise at a bargain price will not move if no one wants to buy it. The same logic applies to stocks. Even when share prices have fallen well below intrinsic value, undervaluation can persist for a long time if investors remain anxious about the future.
That tendency is especially pronounced when an economic slowdown or a deceleration in industry growth is anticipated. When it is hard to be confident that today's strong corporate earnings will hold, investors are reluctant to take on risk.
The yield gap is no different. A reading near historical highs does not guarantee an immediate rebound. Prices can trade sideways for an extended period even as the yield gap stays elevated, and if earnings forecasts deteriorate further, prices could fall again.
PER and yield gap are useful tools for judging how cheap the market has become — not for pinpointing the exact bottom or the precise moment of a recovery.
Even when an undervaluation call proves correct, it can take considerable time for the market to recognize that value. Investors may need to endure not only the risk of further declines but also the tedium of waiting for prices that simply refuse to move.
For that reason, both metrics are more useful to investors with a medium- to long-term horizon than to those chasing short-term gains. They offer limited guidance on whether prices will rise tomorrow or next week, but they can serve as an important reference when deciding whether to increase or reduce equity exposure over a one-to-two-year horizon.
In practice, large institutional investors and pension funds managing significant capital do not need to call the exact bottom. Historically, they reduce exposure when stocks are expensive and gradually build it back up when stocks are cheap — without requiring perfect timing. The longer the investment horizon, the more room there is to exploit current valuation rather than react to short-term market swings.
No industry leads the market forever
There is one more consideration. Even if the market rebounds, not every stock rises with it. Investors cannot afford to overlook the possibility that the sectors driving the next rally may be different from those that led the last one.
The industries that powered the domestic market's advance were, by far, AI and semiconductors. Samsung Electronics and SK hynix delivered historic earnings growth and saw their share prices soar accordingly. But as doubts grow about the pace of AI investment expansion and the US midterm elections shift the policy landscape, a repeat of that performance is far from certain.
History offers a parallel. When electric vehicles and secondary batteries were riding a wave of explosive growth expectations, the share prices of related companies surged. When actual growth fell short of those expectations, prices corrected sharply. It is a reminder that an industry's long-term growth potential and the speed at which its companies' share prices rise do not always move in lockstep.
Even if AI's long-term trajectory remains intact, a slowdown in investment growth or deepening doubts about profitability could send related stocks on a different path. That is why investors cannot assume the previous market leaders will automatically reclaim that role when the market recovers.
Instead, investors should watch for a rotation of market interest toward other sectors. The Democratic Party's sweeping midterm victory could lift attention toward industries poised to benefit from policy tailwinds — healthcare and clean energy among them. It may also prompt capital that had been concentrated in AI and semiconductors to spread into other industries.
Ultimately, investors today need to think about three things at once: how cheap stocks have become, how long they can afford to wait for that value to be reflected in prices, and which industries will lead the market when it turns.
PER and yield gap help answer the first question. They do not answer the second or the third.
Market bottoms are usually only visible in hindsight. More important than trying to call the exact low is making a clear-eyed judgment about whether prices are sufficiently depressed, and then building an investment strategy that can hold through the wait for that judgment to pay off.
Even the cheapest stock delivers nothing if the investor cannot hold on long enough for it to rise. Conversely, even a patient investor may fall short of expected returns if the market's leading sectors have shifted. Now is the time to think not only about where the bottom is, but also about how long to wait — and where to invest when the recovery comes.
th5@heraldcorp.com