Police twice cleared suspect before supplementary investigation led to indictment
Police officers who conducted a flawed investigation into a teenage sexual assault victim's report — ultimately declining to refer the case for prosecution — have been issued official warnings.
The Gyeonggi Nambu Provincial Police Agency announced Monday that it had issued ex officio warnings to two officers from the former Ansan Danwon Police Station who led the investigation at the time, including the investigation team leader.
An ex officio warning is a personnel measure issued directly by a provincial police chief without going through a disciplinary committee, and carries a lighter penalty than formal disciplinary action.
"The decision was made after comprehensively weighing various circumstances," a police official said, adding that the specific grounds and reasoning behind the penalty level could not be disclosed because a related criminal trial is ongoing.
As a result, the specific problems identified in the initial investigation that led to the disciplinary action have not been made public.
According to the findings of a supplementary investigation, suspect A was indicted without detention last month on charges of sexually assaulting Chae, a part-time worker who was 19 at the time, while she was intoxicated and incapacitated at the bar A operated on Dec. 28 last year.
Chae died three days after being notified in February of the police's decision not to refer the case for prosecution, leaving behind a written appeal on her mobile phone in which she protested her innocence.
Police had cleared A after reviewing CCTV footage submitted by A's side that showed Chae smiling, talking and walking shortly after the incident, and taking into account A's statement that the encounter was consensual. Investigators had failed to consider the possibility that Chae had been too intoxicated to resist.
While A appeared multiple times to review the CCTV footage and present his account, Chae was never given the opportunity to view the footage herself. Police said they had followed a "minimize questioning" rule designed to protect victims from secondary harm.
Civil society groups in Gyeonggi Province issued a joint statement saying police had "concluded there was consent based solely on a fleeting moment in the CCTV footage showing the victim smiling and talking," and that investigators had failed to understand what the groups called a "social smile" — a defensive response a young worker would have felt compelled to display under pressure from an employer.
Kim Hong-geun, who was then serving as acting chief of the Gyeonggi Nambu agency, acknowledged the family's demand for an apology, saying he felt "regretful and deeply sorry" and that "there were some shortcomings in the investigation process." On the separate issue of an alleged leak of medical records, Kim said the agency would "conduct a thorough investigation through a supervisory probe and take appropriate measures."
123@heraldcorp.com