Small business federation holds press conference outside National Assembly, demands halt to 'Basic Act for Working People'
'Four major insurances, severance pay burdens to grow, labor disputes to spread' — micro-business owners fear for livelihoods
Government says not all freelancers will be recognized as workers; key issue is who bears the burden of proof
Small business owners are demanding the withdrawal of proposed legislation — the "Basic Act for Working People" and a "worker presumption" provision — being advanced by the government and the National Assembly. They argue that if enacted, the measures would sharply raise labor costs for micro-businesses that rely on special-employment and freelance workers and trigger a surge in severance pay litigation. The small business sector estimates the additional cost per worker would reach about 5.05 million won ($3,780) a year.
The Korea Federation of SMEs and Micro Enterprises held a press conference Tuesday morning in front of the main gate of the National Assembly in Yeouido, Seoul, calling for a halt to what it described as the "work law package" being pushed by the Ministry of Employment and Labor and the Assembly. The federation said the bills fail to account for the payment capacity of small business owners and that sector-by-sector impact assessments and cost reviews must come first.
Song Chi-young, chairman of the federation, said the legislation — which would apply the Labor Standards Act uniformly to special-employment and freelance workers — "fundamentally upends the entire labor market order and drives small business owners into the role of potential criminals." He called it "a classic case of dropping a bomb on an entire house just to catch one mouse."
The industry's central concern is the additional labor cost. According to the federation's analysis, if special-employment and freelance workers are recognized as employees — triggering obligations for four major social insurance contributions and severance pay — business owners would face an added burden of about 420,000 won per worker per month, or about 5.05 million won annually. That figure amounts to roughly 20 percent of the 25 million won average annual operating profit the federation cited for small business owners.
Kim Woo-seok, chairman of the Korea Food Service Industry Association, said that "in a reality where about 75 percent of self-employed operators survive on annual operating profits of 20 million won or less, an additional burden of about 5.05 million won per person is no different from a death sentence," adding that the legislation would "tear down the dam holding up small-business jobs."
Particular concern was raised over the burden of proof that micro-business owners would face in labor disputes if the worker presumption system is introduced. The system shifts the burden of proving employment status onto the employer's side when determining whether a service provider qualifies as a worker. The small business sector warns that litigation costs would fall disproportionately on operators who lack the resources to mount a legal defense.
Pushback also came from the platform industry. Jang Yu-jin, chairman of the Korea Designated Driver Federation, said designated drivers "are not tied to a single company — they choose calls from multiple operators." Treating them uniformly as employees, he said, would force countless small operators to bear litigation costs just to prove they do not qualify as employers.
The government, however, maintains that the system would not recognize all freelancers and platform workers as employees. In an explanatory document released in January, the Ministry of Employment and Labor said the worker presumption system is not designed to expand the definition or scope of workers under the Labor Standards Act, but rather to protect those who are effectively workers in practice but find it difficult to prove that status. The ministry also said the Basic Act for Working People would not immediately apply the Labor Standards Act to all special-employment workers upon enactment.
Ultimately, the central question is how shifting the burden of proof to protect workers would affect the actual costs and hiring practices of micro-businesses. The small business sector fears an increase in disputes over worker status and severance pay claims, while the government believes that placing more of the evidentiary burden on employers — who hold more information — would improve the accuracy of worker-status determinations and reduce unnecessary disputes.
Hwang Gyu-hun, chairman of the Incheon Small Business Federation, said that if labor costs surge, small business owners "will have no choice but to cut staff and replace them with unmanned kiosks and AI." He argued that imposing a uniform system without considering the work structures and fee arrangements specific to each platform sector "will lead to job losses."
hong@heraldcorp.com