Q3 operating loss doubles to 7.2 billion won year-on-year
Debt ratio climbs to 297% as company borrows 31 billion won from owner family
Common shares near 1,000-won floor; preferred shares already flagged for delisting
KleanNara is struggling under a combination of deteriorating earnings, delayed facility investment and a weakening financial structure. Speculation over a management control dispute within the founding family has added to the pressure, and concerns about the viability of its stock market listing have grown as its common share price has fallen toward the 1,000-won threshold.
According to the Financial Supervisory Service's DART system, KleanNara filed its third-quarter report on Monday. The same day, the Korea Exchange warned that KleanNara's first preferred shares had fallen below the market capitalization requirement for continued listing.
KleanNara's consolidated sales for the third quarter reached 135.1 billion won ($101 million), up 2.9 percent from a year earlier, but its operating loss more than doubled — widening from 3.3 billion won to 7.2 billion won. Net loss also expanded, from 7.5 billion won to 10.9 billion won. For the first nine months of this year, the cumulative operating loss stood at 10.5 billion won and the net loss at 21 billion won. While the year-to-date deficit has narrowed compared with the same period last year, losses accelerated again in the third quarter.
The company's financial structure remains fragile. As of the end of September, consolidated total liabilities stood at 465.6 billion won against total equity of 156.7 billion won, pushing the debt ratio up from 273.4 percent at the end of last year to 297.0 percent. Current liabilities of 302.7 billion won are more than double current assets of 149.1 billion won, leaving the current ratio at just 49.2 percent.
KleanNara has also borrowed 31 billion won from members of the founding family — 11 billion won from former Honorary Chairman Choi Byung-min and 20 billion won from his spouse, Koo Mi-jung. Interest expenses on those loans alone came to 709 million won this year. Choi Byung-min is the father of current Chairman Choi Hyun-su, and Koo is the chairman's mother.
A large-scale facility investment is also running behind schedule. In 2023, KleanNara committed 70 billion won to an energy recycling facility and power generation equipment at its Cheongju factory, but the target start date for the new facility has been pushed back from late July this year to April 19 next year. According to the quarterly report, 58.5 billion won of the 65 billion won contract amount has already been spent. The company disclosed that the delay stems from technical adjustments and said it does not expect the postponement to result in losses, as the existing incinerator remains in operation.
Speculation over a management dispute has added further strain. At an extraordinary shareholders' meeting on Nov. 4, a proposal to appoint former Honorary Chairman Choi Byung-min as an inside director was voted down, with only 45.5 percent of shares present voting in favor — short of the required majority. The failed bid to return Choi to the board has fueled speculation about differing views within the founding family over the company's strategic direction.
The share price is also under pressure. KleanNara's common shares closed at 1,113 won on Monday, edging close to the 1,000-won mark. Financial authorities introduced a delisting rule in July this year for so-called penny stocks — shares trading below 1,000 won. Under the rule, a stock that closes below 1,000 won for 30 consecutive trading days is placed on a watchlist, and if it fails to recover above that level within a set period, it becomes subject to delisting.
KleanNara's preferred shares have already received a delisting warning. The company's first preferred shares were placed on a watchlist in September after their market capitalization fell below the 2 billion won threshold, and in the 50 trading days since, the market capitalization has remained below that level on 45 of them. The Korea Exchange disclosed that delisting proceedings will begin if that count reaches 61 days.
hong@heraldcorp.com