Allegations have emerged that The Born Korea CEO Baek Jong-won filed insult charges against hundreds of internet users by distributing complaints across multiple police stations and then collecting settlement payments from them.
Kim Jae-hwan, a YouTuber and former MBC producer, posted a video Tuesday on his YouTube channel "Kim Jae-hwan's Ojaena" raising the allegations under the title "How many people did Baek Jong-won and Lawyer X sue?"
The Born Korea said in September that Baek had filed mass insult complaints against users active in online communities and stock discussion forums. The exact number of people named in the complaints was not disclosed at the time.
Kim said he had confirmed that roughly 40 people each had been named in complaints filed at three separate Seoul police stations, bringing the confirmed total to about 120. A tipster who had been named in one of the complaints checked a list of defendants and found they were numbered in the 40s at that station, Kim said. "A single complaint named 40 people at once," Kim said.
Based on tips from people who had been named, Kim said Baek had filed complaints at more than those three stations. "There are 31 precinct-level police stations in Seoul," Kim said. "If complaints were split across 10 stations with 40 people each, that is at least 400 people. If 25 stations were used, more than 1,000 people could have been named."
Kim offered another line of reasoning. When controversy arose in September over The Born Korea naming shareholders from stock discussion forums, the company said those cases accounted for less than 1 percent of all defendants. Kim said the stock-forum cases amounted to roughly two complaints filed at Eunpyeong Police Station, with additional cases at other stations. Working backward from that figure, he said the total number of defendants reached at least several hundred.
Kim said Baek had not filed complaints at Gangnam Police Station, which covers The Born Korea's main office, or at Bangbae Police Station, which covers Baek's home, but instead spread them across stations in both northern and southern Seoul — including Eunpyeong — with no apparent geographic connection to the parties involved. Kim said splitting the complaints was standard practice for large-scale insult cases. "Imagine filing against 500 to 1,000 anonymous comment writers at a single station — the cybercrime unit would be swamped and the police would hate it," Kim said. "So the common approach is to split them across dozens of stations, not just in Seoul but across the country." Kim added that when the identities of defendants cannot be confirmed, complaints can be filed at any police station nationwide.
Kim said insult charges lend themselves to mass filings. He described what he called an "insult industry value chain" linking comment-monitoring and evidence-collection firms to law firms, with one-stop services covering evidence gathering, complaints, settlements and punishment. "These are companies that profit when there is more insult in our society," Kim said. He also alleged that some operators plant provocative posts to set the tone on message boards, drawing other users into posting insulting content that is then used as the basis for complaints.
Kim said a significant number of those named by Baek had settled their cases. Settlements are typically offered at a level just below the cost of hiring a defense lawyer, making it rational for defendants to pay rather than risk a criminal record, Kim said, adding that minors and university students were especially likely to settle. Settlement amounts in celebrity insult cases have been reported in the range of 2 million to 5 million won ($1,490 to $3,730). Kim calculated that collecting 2 million won each from 250 people would yield 500 million won in settlement revenue.
Kim said the mass complaints had stayed out of the public eye because most cases ended in settlement and the agreements contained confidentiality clauses requiring defendants to pay damages if they disclosed the terms.
"Expression carries responsibility. Who would object to Baek Jong-won filing complaints against people who repeatedly post serious abusive comments?" Kim said. "But if a company and its CEO are gathering evidence in real time on expressions that sit on the line between insult, criticism and satire — sending threatening messages and filing mass complaints to silence people — that company and its CEO deserve to be criticized."
Kim said that "planned, large-scale, click-of-a-button complaints" warranted special scrutiny. "The social cost is too high," Kim said. "The investigation, indictment and trial process — all of that runs on our tax money."
paq@heraldcorp.com