First recruitment in 2014 specified finance, IT and information security experience
Security-related experience requirements dropped from second recruitment onward
All five past presidents came from Financial Supervisory Service deputy governor roles
FSI says professional expertise is verified separately through internal screening
The Financial Security Institute, the financial sector's dedicated cybersecurity body, included information security expertise as one of its requirements when it first recruited a president 12 years ago — but dropped that criterion from the second recruitment onward and has kept it out ever since. With the institute's own systems recently compromised in a hacking incident, questions are being raised about whether security expertise is adequately reflected in the standards used to select its leadership.
According to financial industry sources Wednesday, the FSI's recruitment notice for its fifth president, published in November 2024, listed "the ability and experience to maintain and strengthen active cooperative relationships with member institutions and related organizations" as a qualification. The notice set out four requirements in total: leadership to drive the FSI's growth and development; the professional competence, social standing and moral character to execute duties and lead staff as the head of the organization; and no legal disqualifications for the position. Notably absent were any specific requirements for experience in cybersecurity, incident response or related technical fields.
That stands in contrast to the 2014 notice for the inaugural president. At the time, candidates were required to meet at least one of five experience criteria — including senior civil servant experience in finance, IT or information security; executive management experience in those fields; or at least 10 years of work at a relevant institution. While hands-on security experience was not strictly mandatory, the notice at least laid out concrete, field-specific benchmarks.
The FSI says the information security requirement was removed starting with the second presidential recruitment. The search for the inaugural president in 2014 was conducted by a separate candidate recommendation committee before the institution was formally established; after the FSI launched in 2015, its own presidential candidate recommendation committee took over the process. "The qualifications announced since the institute's founding have emphasized leadership and professional competence as comprehensive capabilities needed to run the organization," an FSI official said. "The intent has not changed."
A notable pattern has emerged in who has actually led the institution: all five presidents since the FSI's 2015 launch have come from deputy governor-level positions at the Financial Supervisory Service. The inaugural president, Kim Yeong-rin, built his career in macroprudential supervision and general operations oversight; the second, Heo Chang-eon, in insurance supervision; and the third, Kim Yeong-gi, in banking and credit finance supervision. The fourth president, Kim Cheol-ung, focused on financial consumer protection and dispute resolution, while the current president, Park Sang-won, handled banking risk and financial group supervision. All five built their careers primarily in financial regulation rather than information security.
The recent hacking of the FSI's own systems has amplified calls to prioritize cybersecurity expertise in selecting the institution's leader. "Officials from a Financial Supervisory Service background have a strong grasp of financial regulation and the supervisory framework, but the technical judgment required for cybersecurity is a separate matter entirely," a security industry official said. "If the head of the organization lacks a sufficient understanding of security technology, there is a risk of focusing on compliance metrics and regulatory adherence rather than developing security policy and making technology investments to counter new threats."
Concerns about the organization's operational independence have also been raised. "The FSI is a nonprofit incorporated association in which financial companies participate as member institutions, but in practice it has sometimes felt like it acts more like a supervisory body," a financial industry official said. "If someone from the regulatory establishment keeps taking the top post, it becomes harder to independently raise problems with existing financial security policies or inspection methods."
Others warned that the current approach may tilt the institution toward managing incidents after the fact rather than preventing them. "When a hacking incident occurs, the response should not stop at coordinating with the supervisory authorities to clean up the damage — what matters is routinely identifying vulnerabilities and improving security systems to keep pace with new attack methods," another official said. "The head of the organization needs to fully understand technical risks in order to incorporate the views of security professionals and properly prioritize security investment and incident response."
The FSI maintains that a president's understanding of financial policy, regulation and the supervisory framework is essential. "The FSI serves as a bridge between financial companies and financial authorities," an FSI official said. "The president is required to have not only information security expertise but also a comprehensive set of capabilities — an understanding of the financial industry, organizational management skills and the ability to build external partnerships."
The institute also pointed to the current president's security-related background. According to the FSI, Park worked for about two years in the Bank of Korea's computer and information division and served for about one year as the officer in charge of information security at the Financial Supervisory Service. Park also held a position overseeing card companies for about one year.
Even without explicit security experience requirements in the published criteria, the FSI says it verifies relevant expertise during the selection process. "The non-public internal screening criteria include an evaluation category for professional expertise," an FSI official said. "Relevant knowledge and experience are assessed comprehensively through document review of self-introductions and management plans, as well as interviews."
snsd@heraldcorp.com