What financial holding companies' Q3 reports show
Banks, brokerages eye corporate loan growth and trading volume recovery
High interest rates seen capping the scale of any earnings rebound
As the Kospi continues to oscillate around the 5,000 mark, the pace of earnings recovery in the financial sector is expected to vary by industry heading into year-end. Brokerages stand to benefit from a rebound in trading volume, and banks are seen improving on the back of corporate loan growth. Card companies and insurers, however, face a slower road to recovery amid funding cost pressures and rising loss ratios.
According to third-quarter reports filed Thursday by major financial holding companies, Hana Financial Group forecast that the domestic stock market would gradually stabilize in the fourth quarter, driven by easing external uncertainty and a return of investment capital. It cautioned, however, that persistent high interest rates and geopolitical risks would keep any rally in check, limiting gains to a technical rebound rather than a broad-based advance, with individual stock performance diverging based on corporate earnings and dividend appeal.
Even without a sharp price rally, a pickup in trading activity could lift brokerage profitability. Hana Financial Group said it expects brokerage revenue to improve on the back of recovering trading volume, with the trading division also seen posting gains quarter-on-quarter. The group noted, however, that the scale of improvement would fall short of previous boom periods due to the lingering effects of high interest rates.
Trading activity had already contracted sharply in the third quarter alongside the broader market pullback. According to Shinhan Financial's quarterly report, the average daily trading value on the domestic stock market — including ETFs — fell 36.2 percent quarter-on-quarter, from 118.1 trillion won ($88.7 billion) in the second quarter to 75.3 trillion won in the third. Customer deposits held in brokerage accounts for share purchases also shrank 14.0 percent from the end of the second quarter to 104.7 trillion won at the end of the third quarter.
In banking, corporate loan expansion is expected to drive earnings improvement. While household loan growth — including mortgage lending — remains constrained by aggregate management caps, business demand and a push to expand productive financing are seen supporting overall loan growth. Net interest margins are also expected to widen gradually as earlier benchmark interest rate hikes feed through to lending rates. Funding costs on deposits and competition to attract prime borrowers through lower lending rates were flagged as factors that could limit profitability.
Card companies are not expected to see meaningful earnings improvement despite a seasonal uptick in consumer spending at year-end. Tighter household debt management is curbing growth in loan-type assets such as card loans, while funding costs and credit loss expenses remain elevated. Deteriorating asset quality among vulnerable borrowers and rising delinquency pressures are seen delaying any meaningful improvement in credit health.
The outlook for insurers is equally challenging. Life insurers face constrained new business activity following the suspension of key whole-life insurance products, with earnings expected to decline due to conservative actuarial assumption changes and experience variance losses. Non-life insurers are likely to see limited top-line growth as they focus on profitability-driven product sales and tighter underwriting standards. A seasonal rise in winter traffic accidents, combined with higher repair and treatment costs, also poses a risk of worsening loss ratios.
Hana Financial Group concluded that even if operating conditions improve for banks and brokerages, the overall scope of earnings recovery across the financial sector will remain limited, weighed down by investment losses from rising interest rates and ongoing funding cost burdens.
rim@heraldcorp.com