SMB·BIO

Similar or different? Coway vs. Cuckoo Homesys water purifier dispute heads to appeal

by
Hong Suk-hee
Published : Nov. 19, 2026 - 15:21:06
    • Copy Completed!

View Korean Original

Cuckoo Homesys unveiled significantly redesigned water purifiers starting in 2024. Coway claimed Cuckoo had copied its water purifier design, but the trial court ruled that the two products create a different aesthetic impression. [Coway, Cuckoo Homesys]
Cuckoo Homesys unveiled significantly redesigned water purifiers starting in 2024. Coway claimed Cuckoo had copied its water purifier design, but the trial court ruled that the two products create a different aesthetic impression. [Coway, Cuckoo Homesys]

Court rules products create 'distinctly different aesthetic impression,' Cuckoo wins first round

Coway appeals ruling, pursues separate patent infringement suit

Coway's ice water purifier patent upheld in separate dispute with Kyowon Wells

A court has sided with Cuckoo Homesys in a legal dispute with Coway over the design of an ice water purifier. Although the two companies' products share notable similarities — including a rectangular exterior and front-panel control placement — the court found that the products create an overall different aesthetic impression. Coway said it will appeal. A separate lawsuit over technology patent infringement is also pending.

According to the rental industry, the Seoul Central District Court dismissed all of Coway's claims on Oct. 15 in a lawsuit seeking a sales ban and damages against Cuckoo Homesys over its "Zero100 Slim Ice Water Purifier." Coway had filed the suit in April last year, alleging that the Cuckoo product infringed on its design rights and constituted an act of unfair competition, and seeking a halt to production and sales, destruction of the product, and compensation for damages.

Coway launched its "Icon Ice Water Purifier" in June 2022, having filed for design registration in March of that year and completing registration in February 2023. Cuckoo released the Zero100 Slim Ice Water Purifier later, in April 2024.

Placed side by side, the two products share similarities in their rectangular front panels, the placement of ice and water dispensing buttons, and their upper and lower structural layouts. However, the court ruled that differences in detailed shapes and control elements meant the two products create an overall different aesthetic impression. The court also noted that the consumer survey Coway submitted as evidence used images that did not sufficiently highlight the distinguishing features of the Cuckoo product.

Cuckoo issued a statement saying a clean, rectangular design is a universal form it has applied not only to water purifiers but also to food waste processors, kimchi refrigerators and rice cookers. The company said the Zero100 Slim Ice Water Purifier had its own registered design rights even before the lawsuit was filed. Cuckoo also suggested that Coway had turned to litigation to keep a competitor in check as rivalry in the rental market intensifies. Cuckoo's cumulative account base stood at 3.28 million as of the first quarter of this year.

The Seoul Central District Court dismissed all of Coway's claims on Oct. 15 in a lawsuit against Cuckoo Homesys seeking a sales ban and damages over the "Zero100 Slim Ice Water Purifier." [Coway, Cuckoo Homesys]
The Seoul Central District Court dismissed all of Coway's claims on Oct. 15 in a lawsuit against Cuckoo Homesys seeking a sales ban and damages over the "Zero100 Slim Ice Water Purifier." [Coway, Cuckoo Homesys]

The legal dispute between the two companies extends beyond design rights. In October, Coway filed a separate lawsuit alleging that Cuckoo's ice water purifier infringed on its core technology patents. The legal questions of design right infringement and technology patent infringement are treated as distinct matters.

Coway has fared better in a separate patent dispute with Kyowon Wells. The Intellectual Property Trial and Appeal Board ruled in June in favor of Coway's correction request in a patent invalidation trial filed by Kyowon Property over water-dispensing technology in ice water purifiers, dismissing the invalidation claims on some patent claims. In May last year, Coway also won a final ruling in a patent infringement case over ice water purifiers that had dragged on for 11 years against Chungho Nais.

Ice water purifiers command higher rental fees than standard water purifiers, making customer acquisition a fiercely competitive arena. The race to miniaturize products and improve ice-making performance is now compounded by an escalating series of design and patent disputes.

"It is disappointing that the ruling did not give sufficient weight to the design confusion and misidentification that actual consumers experience between the two products," a Coway official said. "We plan to actively pursue the appeal to ensure the facts are clearly established."

The official added: "Separately from this design infringement case, we have determined that Cuckoo's ice water purifier also infringes on our core registered technology patents, and we filed a separate patent infringement injunction suit last month. We intend to respond firmly to ensure that intellectual property rights — a company's unique asset — receive the protection they deserve."


hong@heraldcorp.com
This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

MOST READ