Lee Yong-cheol says focus should be on 'uncovering the truth' as special prosecutor law takes effect
Unlike predecessors Jeong Seong-ho and Kim Seung-won, nominee leaves door open on prosecutorial direction
Legal observers say remarks suggest willingness to act on special prosecutor findings
Debate continues despite removal of charge-withdrawal clause from special prosecutor act
Three of President Lee's criminal cases still before first-instance courts, eligible under procedural law
Daejang-dong, SBW and Gyeonggi Province corporate card cases among those without first-instance rulings
"Now is the time to focus on uncovering the truth. Everything else must follow the law and principles."
Those were the words of Justice Minister nominee Lee Yong-cheol as he arrived for his first day at the confirmation hearing preparation office. The remark came in response to reporters asking whether he would be willing to exercise his prosecutorial direction authority depending on the outcome of efforts to establish the facts around charge withdrawals.
Earlier nominees for the post under the Lee Jae Myung administration had drawn a clear line on the question. Jeong Seong-ho, a Democratic Party lawmaker regarded as the leading figure among Lee loyalists who served as the administration's first justice minister, and Kim Seung-won, who co-chaired a Democratic Party caucus pushing for charge withdrawals in President Lee's cases, both publicly ruled out exercising direction authority after being nominated. Lee Yong-cheol, by contrast, was seen as leaving that possibility open. His remarks came as the so-called "fabricated indictment special prosecutor act" — designed to investigate allegations of manipulation in the prosecution and indictment of President Lee Jae Myung and others — was promulgated and took effect. With the special prosecutor's office yet to be launched, attention is now focused on whether Lee will go further at the National Assembly confirmation hearing.
According to legal circles, the Legislation and Judiciary Committee is scheduled to hold a confirmation hearing for Lee on Tuesday. The committee adopted the hearing plan at a plenary session on Wednesday, led by the ruling party. The central issues expected at the hearing are whether charges in President Lee's criminal cases could be withdrawn and whether the justice minister would exercise direction authority over prosecutors. Article 9 of the current Prosecutors' Office Act states that the justice minister, as the highest supervisor of prosecutorial affairs, may generally direct and supervise prosecutors, but may direct and supervise only the prosecutor general in specific cases. While the minister cannot directly withdraw charges in individual cases, the structure allows for direction through the prosecutor general. The opposition People Power Party has been pressing the nominee on the possibility that he could use special prosecutor findings as grounds to direct the withdrawal of charges in President Lee's cases.
The fabricated indictment special prosecutor act passed the National Assembly on Nov. 6 through a unilateral push by the ruling bloc, cleared a Cabinet meeting on Nov. 17, and was promulgated and took effect Thursday. During the legislative process, a provision that would have allowed the special prosecutor to decide whether to maintain charges in existing cases or demand case transfers was removed after repeated controversy. However, because Article 255 of the Code of Criminal Procedure allows charges to be withdrawn before a first-instance verdict is rendered, debate continues that even without the special prosecutor directly withdrawing charges, the Prosecutors' Office could move to do so if the special prosecutor's investigation confirms that past indictments were unlawful.
In practice, three of the five criminal cases President Lee faced have yet to receive first-instance rulings. They are the Daejang-dong, Wirye new town and Baekhyeon-dong development allegations and the Seongnam FC sponsorship case at the Seoul Central District Court, the SBW North Korea remittance case at the Suwon District Court, and the Gyeonggi Province corporate card misuse case. Those trials were suspended after President Lee took office in June last year. The Public Official Election Act violation case, by contrast, was remanded by the Supreme Court with a guilty finding, and the perjury-inducement case was acquitted at the first-instance level — meaning neither is eligible for charge withdrawal under the current Code of Criminal Procedure.
On Nov. 11 morning, as Lee arrived at the confirmation hearing preparation office at the Seoul Immigration Office in Songpa-gu — his first appearance there after the fabricated indictment special prosecutor act cleared the National Assembly — he declined to answer questions about whether he would exercise direction authority over charge withdrawals. "I do not think it is appropriate to offer an opinion on a controversy premised on so much prediction, prejudgment and speculation at a time when the fact-finding process has not even begun," he said. He added that he was not a member of the charge-withdrawal caucus and had never served as defense counsel in any of the cases covered by the special prosecutor act, saying he would "watch the special prosecutor's fact-finding activities going forward without any prejudgment or preconception."
While Lee stopped short of stating a concrete position, legal observers noted that his response differed from those of previous justice minister nominees under the Lee Jae Myung administration, who had publicly pledged there would be no exercise of direction authority. "Even lawmaker Kim Seung-won, who was embroiled in controversy over the charge-withdrawal caucus, could not officially say he would withdraw charges as justice minister," one legal source said. "In Lee's case, it seems he is saying he would make a decision on charge withdrawal based on the special prosecutor's findings."
At his confirmation hearing in July last year, former Justice Minister Jeong Seong-ho answered a question about whether he planned to direct charge withdrawals in cases involving President Lee by saying he believed "it is not desirable for the justice minister to issue instructions on specific cases that could invite political misunderstanding." Although Jeong had previously raised the need for charge withdrawals in President Lee's cases before his nomination, he signaled at the hearing that he opposed ministerial involvement in individual cases — a position he maintained after taking office. In March this year, when speculation arose about an alleged "charge-withdrawal deal," Jeong dismissed the controversy, saying he had "absolutely no intention and no thought whatsoever of directing the withdrawal of charges in any specific case."
Kim Seung-won, nominated to succeed Jeong, also denied any possibility of directing charge withdrawals. On his first day at the confirmation hearing preparation office last September, Kim said the justice minister had "no direct authority" and that he had "no intention of directing through the prosecutor general either." Asked again about the possibility of exercising direction authority, Kim doubled down, saying the decision was "for the prosecutor handling the case to make" and that he had "absolutely no intention of reviewing the minister's direction authority." This came despite Kim having previously co-chaired the Democratic Party caucus pushing for charge withdrawals and a parliamentary investigation into President Lee's cases, where he had been a vocal advocate for withdrawal. After being nominated as justice minister, however, Kim made clear he would not intervene in individual cases.
Lee's past working relationship with President Lee in Seongnam is also expected to come under scrutiny at the hearing. The nominee worked on the transition committee for Lee Jae Myung's tenure as Seongnam mayor in 2010 and later served as chief executive of the Seongnam Industry Promotion Foundation. The People Power Party has cited that connection as grounds to question the nominee's independence and impartiality in carrying out his duties.
yg@heraldcorp.com