Aides appointed to assist end up dominating the bureaucracy — and the political fallout lands squarely on the boss
For a district mayor who won office through an election, a trusted inner circle can feel like a genuine blessing.
These are people who endured the grind of the campaign and remained loyal after the votes were counted. From the district mayor's perspective, they seem like the right people to keep tabs on complex administrative issues and read the mood inside the organization.
That is why district mayors create policy adviser positions and fill them with their closest allies.
That is also where the trouble begins.
The moment someone appointed to assist the district mayor starts acting like the most powerful figure in the building — weighing in on the work of division and department heads — the organization starts to crack.
Word is spreading that civil servants in some of Seoul's autonomous districts are voicing frustration over excessive interference by district mayors' inner-circle policy advisers.
These advisers have been empowered because the district mayor trusts them. But that trust, critics say, is now being wielded in ways that destabilize the formal bureaucratic structure. The deputy district mayor, meanwhile, has been reduced to a figurehead.
"When division and department heads brief the district mayor, the policy adviser sits in and comments on everything — in some cases effectively redirecting the outcome," one senior official in an autonomous district said. "There are proper managers responsible for each area of work, yet everyone ends up watching the adviser's reaction instead. It is suffocating."
Another senior official put it bluntly: "If civil servants put together a solid policy after thorough review and the adviser steps in every time to push it in a different direction, how is anyone supposed to feel motivated to do their job?"
A policy adviser's role is, by definition, to support the district mayor — offering counsel and flagging issues the mayor might otherwise miss.
The problem arises when support becomes interference, advice becomes instruction, and influence begins to override the formal chain of command.
Public organizations have defined hierarchies, authorities and responsibilities. Division directors and department heads are each accountable for their own domains. When an insider with no clear formal authority or accountability inserts themselves into every decision and effectively acts as the final word, the order of the civil service inevitably breaks down.
Civil servants, moreover, cannot simply walk away when they are unhappy. In a public sector where job security is guaranteed, one-sided pressure and interference do not drive the organization forward — they make it sick.
Up to half of civil servants in a given district live in that same community and vote there. When they lose the will to work — when managers dodge responsibility and staff do only what they are told — the consequences reach far beyond the office walls.
Can good policy emerge from an organization like that? Can public administration genuinely serve residents?
Ultimately, the district mayor bears the responsibility. The mayor appointed the adviser; the mayor gave the adviser power. If the mayor knew the adviser was destabilizing the organization and did nothing, that too is a leadership failure.
A district mayor cannot treat an aide's conduct as separate from their own.
Autonomous districts are tight-knit communities. Civil servants, residents and local politicians are all connected. What happens inside a district office spreads through the community faster than most people expect.
Once rumors circulate that an adviser is trampling over civil servants and running roughshod over the organization, the district mayor's own reputation shifts. "The mayor picked the wrong person." "The mayor cannot manage the organization." "The aide has more power than the mayor." Assessments like these are already surfacing in some districts.
As those impressions accumulate, the district mayor's political standing erodes. In some autonomous districts, talk is already emerging that the adviser conduct is making reelection at the next local elections an uphill battle.
For local politicians, such rumors are useful ammunition. Candidates who lost to the mayor in the last election, or figures eliminated in a primary, can raise these issues across the district — and that could become a serious political liability.
Elections are decided by voters, but the political climate heading into an election is shaped by how a mayor governs and manages the organization day to day.
Policy results matter if a district mayor wants to earn residents' trust — but so does how the organization is run. Staff need to trust the mayor, and the organization needs to function steadily, before any policy can deliver results.
Concentrating power in a handful of insiders to control the civil service is not leadership. It may, in fact, be the clearest sign that leadership is absent.
A district mayor should not be someone who exercises power through proxies. The job is to make the entire organization work as it should.
When insiders run amok, civil servants turn their backs. When civil servants turn their backs, the organization falters. When the organization falters, trust in the district mayor falters too.
An inner circle can be an asset or a liability. The moment a district mayor tolerates an aide's overreach, the person closest to the mayor can become the most dangerous political liability. Misuse that trust, and the mayor falls.
District mayors would do well to remember that up to half of their office's civil servants live in the district and vote there.
Four years is not a long time. The political climate heading into the next local elections will also be shaped by the outcome of the 2028 general election.
The power of district office staff should never be taken lightly.
seouldream01@heraldcorp.com