ECONOMY

Exam body apologizes after test-taker marked absent despite sitting labor attorney exam

by
Kim Yong-hun
Published : Nov. 18, 2026 - 21:44:28
    • Copy Completed!

View Korean Original

Proctor's OCR card error slips through internal review; 92% of national exam supervisors sourced externally, raising oversight concerns

A screenshot shows all four subject scores listed as "invalid" for a test-taker who sat the 35th certified labor attorney secondary exam administered by the Human Resources Development Service of Korea. The agency issued a formal apology after a proctor's attendance entry error went undetected during its own review process. [Online community capture]
A screenshot shows all four subject scores listed as "invalid" for a test-taker who sat the 35th certified labor attorney secondary exam administered by the Human Resources Development Service of Korea. The agency issued a formal apology after a proctor's attendance entry error went undetected during its own review process. [Online community capture]

The Human Resources Development Service of Korea mistakenly recorded a test-taker who sat this year's certified labor attorney secondary exam as absent, causing all four of the candidate's subject scores to appear as invalid in the results system.

The agency acknowledged that the proctor's entry error was not caught during its own internal review process.

The incident follows a recent scandal over AI-assisted cheating in the certified tax accountant exam and has drawn fresh criticism over persistent gaps in the management of national qualification tests.

According to the agency, one test-taker in the 35th certified labor attorney secondary exam — held Aug. 29 and 30 — was confirmed to have been incorrectly recorded as absent. The agency issued a formal apology Wednesday and said it would correct the candidate's attendance status.

The error came to light on the day results were announced. A post on an online community for labor attorney exam candidates described entering an examinee number only to find scores for all four subjects — labor law, administrative litigation law, management and organizational theory, and human resources management — listed as "invalid." The poster said they contacted the agency's customer service center to complain and were told the scores were being re-entered.

Created with ChatGPT
Created with ChatGPT

The agency traced the problem to a proctor's error in recording attendance. The proctor incorrectly marked the candidate's status on the supervisor's OCR card used to verify attendance and absences against the official examinee roster, causing a test-taker who was present to be processed as absent.

More troubling was that the error survived the agency's own verification process. In its apology, the agency acknowledged it "failed to detect the attendance entry error during the first-stage review of the incorrectly filled OCR card and the absence records." A simple clerical mistake by a proctor thus went uncorrected for roughly 80 days — all the way to the day successful candidates were announced.

The agency said it would promptly reclassify the candidate from absent to present, produce a scored result, and notify the individual directly.

The incident has also put a spotlight on the national qualification exam system's heavy reliance on external supervisory staff. Data submitted to Democratic Party of Korea lawmaker Lee Yong-woo by the agency showed that more than 4.4 million people sat national qualification exams the agency administered last year.

A total of 468,000 person-sessions of exam supervision were required, yet agency employees accounted for only about 39,000 of those — roughly 8 percent. The remaining 92 percent were filled by outside personnel, including school teachers and retired police officers. Supervisors receive an allowance of 105,000 won ($78) for a six-hour shift.

Critics say the use of external proctors is not inherently problematic, but the fact that a proctor's clerical error could invalidate a candidate's scores — and go undetected internally — points to the need for a comprehensive review of supervisor training and attendance verification procedures. The criticism is particularly sharp given that the government has already moved to tighten oversight of national qualification exams following revelations that the top scorer on the certified tax accountant exam had used AI to cheat.

Lee Byung-hoon, president of the Human Resources Development Service of Korea, said the agency "sincerely apologizes for failing to detect the error in advance as the body responsible for administering the exam," and pledged to "put follow-up measures in place to ensure that the credibility of our exams is never again undermined by a problem of this kind."

Meanwhile, the agency announced Wednesday that 460 candidates passed the 35th certified labor attorney secondary exam — 42 more than the 418 who passed last year and the highest number since 2022, when a record 549 candidates cleared the test.


fact0514@heraldcorp.com
This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

MOST READ