Committed offense while on probation for attempted murder of father
Court: evidence shows defendant pressured mother to change testimony
A woman in her 20s who had previously received a suspended sentence for attacking her father with a weapon has been sentenced to prison after threatening and assaulting her mother with a weapon while still on probation.
The Chuncheon District Court's Criminal Division 1-3, presided over by Chief Judge Heo Il-seung, upheld the original sentence of one year in prison for the defendant, identified only as A, 25, who was indicted on charges of aggravated threatening, aggravated assault and aggravated property destruction against a lineal ascendant.
A was charged after getting into a dispute with her mother, identified as B, 45, while the two were drinking at an apartment in Wonju, Gangwon Province, in March. The argument stemmed from a disagreement over the inheritance of her grandfather's estate, during which A allegedly threatened and assaulted B with a weapon.
According to the investigation, A became enraged after learning that her mother had renounced the grandfather's inheritance without consulting her. A then threatened B, saying she would kill her dog and that she would kill the entire family and go to prison.
When B retreated to the bedroom holding her pet dog, A followed and assaulted her by grabbing her hair and shoulder. A also faces charges of smashing a dining table worth 1 million won ($751) with a metal tumbler taken from the kitchen.
During the trial, A denied threatening or assaulting her mother while holding a weapon.
The court of first instance ruled, however, that even if A had not been holding the weapon directly, keeping it within reach and ready for use at any moment constituted carrying a dangerous object.
The court also rejected A's claims, citing her prior history of threatening her mother with a weapon and the fact that B had been in such urgent distress that she asked an acquaintance to call the police on her behalf.
While taking into account that B did not wish to see her daughter punished, the court sentenced A to one year in prison, stating that "the defendant committed this offense against her biological mother while on probation for the attempted murder of her biological father, making the nature of the crime poor and the potential for social condemnation significant."
On appeal, A argued that because she had not been carrying a weapon, only the lesser charges of threatening and assaulting a lineal ascendant — rather than the aggravated versions — should apply. Since those lesser offenses cannot be prosecuted when the victim does not wish to press charges, A contended that the indictment should be dismissed given that her mother had expressed a desire not to pursue punishment.
The appeals court, however, focused on the fact that B had given a detailed account to police immediately after the incident, stating that A had held a weapon and threatened her dog with it.
B later changed her account during the prosecution's investigation and at the first trial, saying she had not directly seen A holding a weapon. The court nonetheless found, based on recordings of jail and prison visits, that A had pressured her mother to retract her testimony.
The court determined that B had a motive to change her testimony in order to shield her daughter from punishment, and that her explanation for the reversal was difficult to accept, concluding that the original statement was more credible.
The appeals court also dismissed A's argument that the sentence was too harsh, ruling that "the sentencing by the court of first instance fell within a reasonable exercise of discretion," and upheld the one-year prison term.
quq@heraldcorp.com