Industrial electricity rates up 65% in 3 years, squeezing root-industry firms
76.4% of root-industry SMEs unable to pass on electricity cost hikes to buyers
Energy indexing expansion takes effect Dec. 3 — enforceability remains key
Kim, the head of a forging company in Hwaseong, Gyeonggi Province, has been wrestling with a difficult question lately. The government is set to allow energy cost increases to be reflected in supply prices starting in December, but Kim worries that pushing for higher prices could cost the company its clients. "There are many suppliers out there," Kim said. "If we ask our buyer to raise the unit price and they go looking for another supplier, it could put the whole company in a very difficult position."
Park, who runs a forging company in Jincheon-gun, North Chungcheong Province, sees the situation differently. "Our buyer has been doing business with us for a long time. If they cut ties with us, it won't be easy for them to find a replacement supplier either," Park said. "Electricity costs have risen sharply, and once the government policy takes effect, we plan to calculate our energy costs and bring them to the negotiating table." The company supplies bumper components for vehicles to an automaker.
According to the small and medium-sized enterprise sector Wednesday, an amended version of the Act on Promotion of Mutually Beneficial Cooperation Between Large Enterprises and Small and Medium Enterprises takes effect Dec. 3, expanding the scope of supply-price indexing from key raw materials to major energy costs. Transactions in which major energy costs account for 10 percent or more of the supply price will be subject to indexing. Under the system, if energy costs fluctuate beyond a threshold agreed upon in advance by the contracting parties — within a 10 percent margin — the change must be reflected in the supply price. The measure was introduced to ease the cost burden on root industries such as casting, forging and heat treatment, which consume large amounts of energy.
Linking energy costs to supply prices has long been a priority for the root industry sector. "The supply-price indexing system was introduced, but energy costs had been excluded from its scope all along," an official from the metal heat treatment industry said. "As a result of the industry's consistent calls for change, we now have an opportunity to reflect energy costs, including electricity bills, in supply prices. Industrial electricity rates have risen sharply in recent years, significantly eroding profitability for small and medium-sized enterprises."
According to the Korea Federation of SMEs, industrial electricity rates — the industrial-use, high-voltage Type A tariff — rose 64.9 percent, from 105.5 won per kilowatt-hour in the first quarter of 2022 to 174.0 won in the fourth quarter of 2024. Electricity costs also account for a substantial share of manufacturing expenses. In a survey of 700 root-industry small and medium-sized enterprises conducted last year, the federation found that 81.4 percent of respondents said electricity costs made up 10 percent or more of their total manufacturing costs. By sector, the figure was highest in heat treatment at 99.3 percent, followed by surface treatment at 85.7 percent, casting at 79.3 percent and mold-making at 75.7 percent. Among heat treatment firms specifically, 81.4 percent said electricity accounted for more than 20 percent of their manufacturing costs.
The problem is that despite rising electricity costs, the existing structure of contractual relationships has made it difficult for suppliers to push for higher prices. In the same survey, 90.1 percent of respondents said rising electricity costs had placed a burden on their operations, yet 76.4 percent said they had not asked their buyers to reflect the increases in supply prices. Among those who had not made such a request, 69.3 percent cited concern over damaging the business relationship as their reason.
Among companies that had been unable to pass electricity cost increases on to buyers, 70.1 percent said they had no particular way to cope. Some 25.4 percent said they were supplying products below cost in order to preserve the business relationship. Meanwhile, 90.0 percent of surveyed companies supported including electricity costs in the indexing system, and 77.3 percent said they intended to use the system once it was in place.
The government has also been paying attention to the energy cost burden facing the root industry. Fair Trade Commission Chairman Ju Byung-gi visited the factory of Alus, an aluminum specialist in Jincheon-gun, North Chungcheong Province, in April and held a meeting with root industry representatives. Officials from the Korea Forging Industry Cooperative and the heat treatment cooperative were among those who attended. Industry participants called for advance education on the expanded indexing system and support for cost analysis covering raw materials and energy expenses.
Concerns remain about blind spots in the energy indexing system. Under the current law, transactions with a contract period of 90 days or less, a supply price of 100 million won ($74,900) or less, or where the commissioning company is a small enterprise are exempt from the obligation to conclude an indexing agreement. Transactions in which both parties agree not to apply indexing are also exempt. If these loopholes are exploited, companies could avoid reflecting energy costs such as electricity in supply prices by splitting contracts into periods of 90 days or less, or by routing commissions through small-enterprise affiliates.
The Korea Federation of SMEs co-hosted a briefing session Tuesday with the Korea Price Association on practical strategies for the energy indexing system and how to use the supply-price adjustment platform. The federation also built an online system that allows users to draft standard indexing contracts, run simulated supply-price calculations, and file applications for supply-price adjustment consultations.
"As the energy indexing system approaches, it is important for small and medium-sized enterprises to fully understand how to calculate energy costs and how to conclude indexing agreements, and to prepare in advance so they can apply the system in actual transactions," said Yang Chan-hoe, executive vice president of the Korea Federation of SMEs.
hong@heraldcorp.com