Cooperative holds press conference, citing 2007 agreement on usage rights after free-use period
Busan city says agreement violates current shared-property law
Cooperative urges city to submit facility-by-facility implementation plan by Nov. 30
Some 300 vendors call on Busan to honor signed commitments
Vendor representatives of the Busan Fish and Seafood Processing Cooperative, which operates the Jagalchi modernized market, urged the city of Busan Thursday to honor a 2007 usage agreement and devise a lawful alternative, amid the market's 20-year free-use period set to expire Nov. 30. The cooperative held a press conference at 11 a.m. at the Busan City Council briefing room, saying it was "appealing against the unreasonableness of Busan's administration as vendors who have kept this market for more than 56 years," and called for proactive action from the city.
The cooperative's core argument rests on a usage agreement signed April 23, 2007. Article 3, Paragraph 2 of the agreement stipulated 20 years of free use beginning Dec. 1, 2006, while Paragraph 3 guaranteed usage rights corresponding to the cooperative's cost share both during and after the agreement period. The cooperative said the expiration of the free-use period and the city's promise to guarantee subsequent usage rights are separate matters, and that the latter constitutes a public-law obligation the city must fulfill.
The cooperative also released supporting documents, saying the clause was in fact discussed during negotiations. According to records it holds, the city's initial draft in October 2006 barred the cooperative from claiming any rights over its cost share. The cooperative said it demanded a usage-rights guarantee clause at a modernization negotiations committee meeting on March 26, 2007, and that the city's response three days later, on March 29, incorporated the language, which remained in the final signed document.
The cooperative said it understood that the head of the city's maritime capital strategy office had told a City Council administrative audit that the agreement violated the shared-property law, and added that it disagreed with that assessment. The cooperative rebuffed the city's position, saying the agreement could not be deemed unlawful from the time of signing simply because current law restricts extensions of free use. It also called on the city, if it intended to deny the agreement's validity, to clarify which specific clauses it was challenging, what laws were in effect at the time of signing, and whether the challenge applied to individual provisions or the agreement as a whole.
The cooperative said it was not seeking permanent use of the entire facility or the authority to grant or revoke individual vendor licenses, and asked the city to open discussions first on the first and second floors and the ancillary facilities needed for operations. According to the cooperative, between 330 and 340 vendors are currently operating at the Jagalchi modernized market, including 290 cooperative members and 40 to 50 non-members.
Busan city issued a notice on Nov. 2 announcing the return of stalls and inviting applications for paid-use permits. Under the plan, the Busan Facilities Corporation would take over management of the market from Dec. 1, when the free-use period ends, while vendors currently in operation would be granted discretionary permits. The cooperative, whose members are mostly subletting, pushed back and held rallies at the city hall plaza for three days beginning Nov. 9. The vendors also argued that the cooperative had borne 16 billion won ($12 million) of its own funds during the market's modernization, covering land reclamation from shared waters, construction of a temporary market and construction of the new market.
In its Nov. 11 response, the city said it could not accept direct management delegation to the cooperative, but acknowledged the cooperative's experience and expertise and said it would consider dividing responsibilities between the Busan Facilities Corporation and the cooperative for seawater supply and facility handover, as well as a three-way working-level meeting. In response, the cooperative called on the city to suspend its unilateral administrative measures and begin consultations immediately under Article 7 of the agreement.
The cooperative asked the city to submit in writing by Nov. 30 a facility-by-facility plan for implementing the agreement and an operational plan for the first day of the transition. "What we are trying to protect is not just the name Jagalchi, but a market that citizens and visitors can trust and return to," the cooperative said, urging the city to honor its signed commitments and "prepare the next 50 years of Jagalchi together with the vendors on the ground."
kaf2002@heraldcorp.com